this post was submitted on 31 Oct 2024
216 points (99.1% liked)

Comic Strips

12355 readers
2846 users here now

Comic Strips is a community for those who love comic stories.

The rules are simple:

Web of links

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 
all 32 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 6 points 2 hours ago

He unlearned the ability from thousands of years underground.

[–] [email protected] 6 points 4 hours ago

Obvuously, they took the eagles!

[–] [email protected] 17 points 6 hours ago

They had "wings of shadow," not physical wings.

[–] [email protected] 79 points 10 hours ago* (last edited 9 hours ago) (1 children)

"A complete consistency (either within the compass of the Silmarillion itself or between The Silmarillion and other published writings of my father's) is not to be looked for, and could only be achieved, if at all, at heavy and needless cost."

  • Christopher Tolkien
    The Silmarillian Forward, 1977
[–] [email protected] 20 points 7 hours ago (1 children)

It's similar to searching for consistencies amongst any mythology, which is what Tolkien was attempting to create. Tales will always change over time, and they'll always shift focus to what the teller determines is important. As focuses of a society shift, so do the focuses of its related mythology. In this way, I think Tolkien did an excellent job creating a united mythos for England in all the different versions of his legendarium. As the tales evolved, consistencies emerged elements which were formerly key, were discarded, and internal references became more commonplace than external references (see Tolkien's influences from William Morris and Icelandic, Celtic, Germanic, and Anglo Saxon epics)

[–] [email protected] 10 points 6 hours ago (1 children)

That was the challenge Christopher noted in the forward to the Silmarillion. J.R.R. had started working it in 1917, and kept making changes right up until his death in 1973.

So he had 56 years worth of papers, and notes, lots of it hand written, to try to kind of reconcile into a single work.

[–] [email protected] 6 points 6 hours ago (1 children)

It's been a few years since I've read the foreword to the Silmarillion, but I'm glad I'm consistent with Christopher's analysis 😁

[–] [email protected] 6 points 6 hours ago

Helps that I literally just read it the day before this post! LOL.

[–] [email protected] 48 points 9 hours ago (3 children)

If I pushed an albatross down a well and attached a crab to it to harrass it on the way down it would also fall, despite being a fantastic winged flier.

Imagine them with wings ill suited to vertical flight and hovering, but very fast in the sky while soaring, and with the endurance to keep going for hours.

It's my headcannon, but I give Gandalf points for forcing the fighter jet into a helicopter arena.

[–] [email protected] 8 points 5 hours ago

It’s my headcannon, but I give Gandalf points for forcing the fighter jet into a helicopter arena.

Gold

[–] [email protected] 3 points 5 hours ago

Is Gandolf the Camo bringing the fighter jets to helms deep on the third morning not cannon?

[–] [email protected] 6 points 7 hours ago (1 children)
[–] [email protected] 3 points 5 hours ago

Or powerwalked really fast.

[–] [email protected] 31 points 10 hours ago (2 children)

These are divine beings. Their speed doesn't necessarily imply how they got from point A to point B so quickly.

[–] [email protected] 23 points 10 hours ago* (last edited 9 hours ago) (3 children)

The balrog in Moria was chasing the fellowship. If it could move at 400 mph (by any means) then it would have caught them immediately. We know that some balrogs are weaker than others since it is said that Gothmog was the mightiest. My conclusion is that if the balrogs literally flew by mundane means to Melkor's aid, then the balrog in Moria was particularly weak (and cowardly) and did not participate in rescuing Melkor. I presume that's also why it hid deep underground for so long rather than fighting and being banished along with the other balrogs.

With that said, I think Melkor summoned the balrogs to himself by magical means (but they can't teleport on their own). None of them could go 400 mph. That's just silly. They're not Sonic the Hedgehog. I also think that balrogs can't fly. The word "wings" is a metaphor for the way flames spread from them.

(I don't claim that the text rules out the possibility of wings and flight. The balrog might have fallen with Gandalf because they fought a metaphysical battle, dragged down by the "weight of its sin".)

Edit: I think we actually agree. I'm just elaborating.

Edit 2: I found a picture that shows what I think a balrog's "wings" look like.

[–] [email protected] 13 points 7 hours ago

In the Second Prophecy of Mandos (present in most versions of Tolkien's Quenta Silmarillion, but omitted from the final Silmarillion due to a perceived incompatibility by Christopher Tolkien), it's mentioned that Melkor will emerge from the door of night after the world and it's powers grow old and weary (the powers being the Ainur, which includes the Balrogs). This indicates that even the gods will grow old and fade as the elves do, which could imply that Durin's Bane is actually just faded and weakened from age and inactivity, since the balrog was sleeping under the mountain for ~5400 years (assuming it participated in the final battle of the war of wrath and hid itself under Khazad-dûm immediately after Melkor's expulsion). Also, there were no more than 3 or 7 balrogs ever according to later writings by Tolkien, which indicates that no balrog was weak or cowardly.

In regards to Melkor's wailing and summoning of the balrogs: Ungoliant ensnared Melkor in Lammoth, which is described as being near the ruins of Angband where the balrogs awaited Melkor's return. It is said that the balrogs rushed swiftly to Melkor's aid, but there is no indication that the wailing was short. In fact, Lammoth is also known as the land of "the Great Echo" where the wailing of Melkor could still be heard ever after, which to me indicates that the wails were prolonged and intense rather than a swift "yelp" followed by a rescue. With this interpretation, it makes sense to me that the balrogs marched quickly, but still took time to rescue Melkor, which would eliminate the possibility of teleportation or sonic the hedgehog running.

Another interesting writing to note is the involvement of balrogs riding flying fire drakes in the Fall of Gondolin. Now, the Fall of Gondolin is definitely an unfinished tale, and was "neglected" more than the other two great tales/lays of Tolkien's later focus, but there are still consistencies between versions that indicate a certainty of specific elements in Tolkien's mind. In each version, there is mention of balrogs riding to battle atop flying fire drakes to assail the city while orcs and trolls attempt to break the walls. This would indicate to me that balrogs could not fly unaided, which would make any wings they have vestigial (unlikely since they are divine), or more a "cloak" of fire.

[–] [email protected] 8 points 9 hours ago

The Moria Balrog was just a little baby Balrog who couldn't fly yet.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 9 hours ago (1 children)

None of them could go 400 mph. That’s just silly

And completely in keeping with every other facet of fantasy if you want to be that way. A Baalrog can go 400mph just as easily as Gandalf could teleport. All it takes is the stroke of a pen.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 8 hours ago* (last edited 8 hours ago) (1 children)

That's true in a trivial sense: there's no law of nature that enforces verisimilitude in any work of fiction. However, most authors aim for verisimilitude, and the good ones achieve it. I'm not talking about the top speeds of balrogs because I think there's some objective answer, but rather because I think that Tolkein does achieve verisimilitude (at least in some regards) and therefore there is a foundation for discussing the traits of his fictional beings. He easily could have given balrogs rocket skates, but he didn't.

[–] [email protected] 18 points 9 hours ago* (last edited 9 hours ago)

Maybe they require a large horizontal distance to take off, like a plane

Basically the balrog stalled out

[–] [email protected] 6 points 8 hours ago (1 children)

So when Gandalf said "fly, you fools" to the fellowship, he was ordering them to sprout wings and fly away?

[–] [email protected] 7 points 8 hours ago* (last edited 8 hours ago)

He was saying, just take the eagles dumbasses