I have a Sonos speaker, and the fact that I'm forced to use their app that still sucks has definitely caused me to look elsewhere for my next similar device.
this post was submitted on 25 Aug 2024
163 points (99.4% liked)
Technology
58303 readers
15 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
Approved Bots
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
What do you use the app for? I used it for initial setup and setting alarms, but haven’t tried the new app yet. I mostly use the Spotify app over airplay to play on SONOS, or Alexa
Because of their dumb spat with Google, I can't connect my Android devices to it via Cast. So if you use Android at all, you have to do all your searches and such through the Sonos app, which is laid out so horribly.
ETA: and I'm not buying an iPhone just so I can have a better user experience that used to work before they intentionally broke it.
At least Spotify has a built in button to just select one of their speakers, so you can use that one to bypass their shitty app.
That said, I don't think you can select multiple speakers, which kind of defeats the purpose of a multi room sound system. So yeah, I haven't uninstalled their app and get annoyed as fuck every time I have to use it.
They deserve what they get. Obviously, they didn't take consumer loyalty seriously, and now they're reaping the consequences.
I use Alexa->Sonos->Plex to avoid Android. But that's because Google music folded up back in the day in her refuse to pay Google for any of the music I already own.
I had been meaning to check if they had unfucked everything.
Sounds like no.
I hardly use my Sonos speakers now since the big update. I just replay what I have in the queue and hope it doesn't fail to connect.
Other than the soundbar on my TV, the thing I use it for 90% of the time is an alarm that pays lullabies for my kids from Navidrome. I had to revert the android app and tell everything to never upgrade.
When Sonos first came out, they had this really easy to use, standalone device. It had a track wheel like the old iPods, buttons, and a color display. That made it easy for non-tech people to browse and choose what to play. Then they decided to drop that and go the app route. It's been downhill ever since.
I’m the complete opposite of its users apparently. I never use the Sonos app to play music (it’s been crap for that before 2.0). I just airplay through iOS’s system and enjoy its multi-room audio in bliss. I didn’t buy a Sonos system to integrate other Sonos device with it. I bought it to integrate with other Airplay devices and be my living room sneaker surround setup (an Arc+sub gen 3+lamp Symfonisks). Again, the app has always sucked compared to favorite Music/Podcast app + Airplay 2.
Same, I stream using the airplay protocol from my Lyrion Music Server and haven't had to touch their app since they arrived. If they fuck with that though so help me god I will write the nastiest things about them on the internets.
I'm the opposite too, for a different reason to you. I have Sonos home theatre (soundbar, sub, rear speakers) and Chromecast with Google TV hooked up to the TV. I control music on a pixel phone or pixel tablet through the Chromecast, Sonos kinda just hangs off on the edge of my ecosystem and I don't think about it. I maybe use the app a few times a year.
But I get why if you just have a few speakers it would be a pain to use the app.
Somebody much smarter than me needs to hack this system. I’d pay to support it.
It’s beyond BS that functionality gets deleted from a product I purchased. I knew the risk of investing into an ecosystem that “required” an app to work. Shame on me, I get what I deserve I guess. Still doesn’t make it right.
i just use 15 year old apple airports that you can find for dirt cheap used and they do airplay 2.0 perfectly, and i haven't had to restart them in several years. then plug them into whatever aux speaker you want.
I dont use iPhone but my mom does . Are you saying that AirPods can be used as a "receiver" and play music through Jack?
How do you go about that, are you charging them constantly? Is it the box or the ear thing that has the output?
sorry not airpods. check out apple airport express. they were wired to the wall and have an audio out jack. apple abandoned them a decade ago but they are rock solid.
Airport. Not Airpod. A lot of people don't remember them.
Yeah sorry I was assuming it was a mistake
It took me 2 solid hours to find a work around to get my parent's speaker working again. Thanks Sonos!
The new app sucks, but that's been true for quite some time. I have a bunch of older Sonos stuff that's still runs their old 'S1' app. It works perfectly. When I need to add a zone I buy old hardware on eBay that is still S1 compatible. What this article doesn't mention but should, is the newer versions of the new app have a much less robust privacy policy and even more stuff is being done through their cloud. It's not necessary, it doesn't help user experience, it just gives more data to harvest, and it's not what consumers want.
It's good that they are trying to right the ship. But this article nails it on the head, whatever they are doing now is way too late. Management that's not asleep at the switch would have seen these problems before the app even launched and slammed on the brakes lest they destroy their company to get a pair of headphones out the door. And that's exactly what they did. The trust of users is broken, that's not easily repaired. They shipped their headphones but nobody gave a shit because the app made people want to get rid of Sonos entirely.
It's too bad Logitech discontinued the Squeezebox line. At the time that was the biggest competitor to Sonos, they could be cleaning up right now.