unlawfully hacking a Nintendo Switch console
What? It's my hardware, Apple lost his battle with jailbreaking years ago, Nintendo just shit out an already lost argument.
this post was submitted on 27 Feb 2024
238 points (98.0% liked)
Linux Gaming
15500 readers
54 users here now
Gaming on the GNU/Linux operating system.
Recommended news sources:
Related chat:
Related Communities:
Please be nice to other members. Anyone not being nice will be banned. Keep it fun, respectful and just be awesome to each other.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
This is not really the same thing.
The Apple lawsuit was about running unsigned code on the iPhone, which courts deemed that Apple couldn't use copyright as a tool to enforce its walled garden.
Nintendo isn't arguing about people modifying their switch to run homebrew. They're arguing that to use Yuzu you need to provide it with a copy of the decryption keys and system firmware which must be either extracted from a Switch or distributed illegally.
This is a much stronger case in Nintendo's favor, than the Apple jailbreak one. Although, I suspect the Yuzu dev has a better case as it's already legal to back up discs and ROMs as long as you dont distribute them and they're not responsible for other people's actions if they choose to break copyright
IIRC Sony lost their lawsuit which was almost identical to Nintendo's. I'm guessing they are hoping for a far friendlier conservative court.
spoiler
asdfasdfsadfasfasdf
No, it's not.
The case Sony lost also relied on the end user having a blob of Sony's code. A user using their own key and a blob of Nintendo's firmware, which is the official stance of Yuzu on the correct way to do so, is exactly the same thing. There's nothing new to be litigated. Every part of Yuzu is very clearly legal.
The fact that it was used to play a game before official release straight up cannot possibly be relevant. It's a distraction. The project isn't, and isn't capable of being, responsible for anything but its own code.
safasfaf
By existing. (Yes, that's the only argument they made. There is no assertion that anyone associated with Yuzu "cracked" (not necessary) or actively distributed TOTK.)
It's a distraction. It's literally impossible for it to be relevant unless the yuzu project page hosted TOTK files.
asdfsafdfaf
They lost, but killed the dev through attrition.
Emulation has also been litigated to hell and is also very clearly legal.
As long as they don't distribute copyrighted material, they should be good. Hopefully a judge throws this out due to no evidence of actual copyright violation.
Yeah. That bit stood out to me as well. I posted in the other cross-post that I wonder if that means Nintendo's going to try to go after stuff like Atmosphere and Hekate etc next.
The hacking discords were just hit with another wave of bans across the board. Sure, a lot of them were sharing piracy links, but I know of several that clearly weren't and still got nuked. Nintendo is going hard into repression, next step is probably going to be going after modchip sellers.
They probably know they'll lose. But they can drag Yuzu creators through court and bleed them dry in the process.
We should ban the practice of tying software to hardware, and the creation of arbitrary restrictions for such practices.
In my opinion there are a few legitimate cases for piracy and platform exclusives is one of them. And these pirates prove it's completely possible for Nintendo to make it available for sale on other platforms. If Nintendo doesn't make it available for sale, it should be a free-for-all. I don't want to buy a Switch. I don't want to buy an Xbox or a PS5. Not to mention paying the 30% Nintendo tax for the privilege of creating a game that actually runs on it. And I don't want to feed any of these megacorporations my telemetry. Fuck 'em.
Sony tried the same thing with geohotz and lost.
Ugh, not this again. I'm very adamantly against piracy and I've personally dumped every one of my Switch ROMs from games I physically own, but these kinds of stunts make me want to pirate Nintendo games purely out of spite. Hopefully this gets thrown out or otherwise resolved quickly. The issue of clean room emulators has been tested before and found to be fair use and to my knowledge there's no legal precedent for Nintendo's claims.
Why would anyone play your games on hardware that's ten years behind? The few Nintendo games I still buy (like Tears of the Kingdom actually) I still play on emulator, because it's objectively better in every way. Fuck off.
Seeing Tears of the Kingdom actually run in 60 fps on the steamdeck made me immediately sell my Switch. Nintendo are holding back technological development by dragging their feet, and pushing anti-consumer practices.
I’ve been working to build a large collection of DS and 3DS games that I still enjoy to this day on the original hardware.
As a side rant, the 3DS/2DS really is a great console. It has a huge catelog of affordable games that can be purchased used from eBay and it doesn’t have the requirement to be online like the switch does. I took my switch off grid a while ago and was mega disappointed to find I couldn’t play a single game without “updates” because this wasn’t my “primary console” (a concept I didn’t realize existed or mattered).
Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
Go multi platform and a large chunk of the people currently pirating Switch games for emulation will just buy your games instead.
I'd absolutely buy switch ROMs, even for 60€. Just gimme a damn download link.
As an example I've paid for a copy of Breath of Fire 3, 3 times in my life, because the disc broke twice over the years. Now my ps1 & 2 are caput. I still own a copy of the disk. Would it be illegal to download an emulator (I've boughten 2 ps1 and 4 ps2 in my lifetime) and a rom of BoF3? Sony got their cut 9 times already.
If buying isnt owning then pirating isnt stealing in my humble opinion.
Some might argue you would need to copy the ROM from the disc you own instead of downloading it from the internet.
Luckily for the PS2 this is trivial for anyone with a PC and a disc drive.
What about when the Switch is no longer supported just like the 3DS? The only way to get those games now is other online avenues, or searching local stores which aren't promising anymore.
safafaf
@sirsquid now that modchips are open source and cost like $15 instead of being made by one company for $90, they seem desperate and are looking for some case that they might win