Cocodapuf

Ok, so let's say you're a performer and from time to time people yell something at you while you're on stage. Given the context, let's divide all comments into two categories.

1. Commentary on your performance. These could be statements like "wwooooooo!", "you suck!", "I love you!", "get off the stage!" or "play free bird".

2. Other bullshit. This includes any comments not about your music or the performance currently in progress. Basically anything off topic or not covered by category 1.

If someone yelled "do you support genocide?", what category would you put that in?

Now once you've answered that question, I want you to remember that your answer doesn't actually matter at all either way. Because in the end, a performer on stage is never obligated to respond to anything yelled at them from the floor.

But you're right I guess, "political issue" was the wrong way to frame it. I should have said "other bullshit" (as laid out above).

It was both. It was a rhetorical question, which are technically questions while being functionally statements.

It's worth noting though, arguing this semantic point doesn't change anything or win any argument, it's just pedantic.

No actually, I don't like Thom Yorke. My problem was with a dumb comment trying to sound logical by throwing fancy words around.

If you want to use Occam's razor in this situation, (a pretty inappropriate situation, because who can truly know what others are thinking or feeling) then I'll show you how that works...

Occam's razor: He walked off because he was in a bad mood and didn't really feel like playing that show in the first place. The crowd comment seemed like a good enough excuse to walk off. That is probably the simplest solution.

I shower in the morning, just after I take my ADHD meds. My shower thoughts are... meandering. Occasionally insightful, but usually just weird rabbit holes where I ponder links between distantly removed topics.

Well he's not Tony Stark...

Occam's razor doesn't really apply here... You can't use that to just assert that he supports Israel. Besides, he later did say that he doesn't support Israel.

Honestly, I can understand the response. He's in the middle of a set and someone starts yelling about some political issue... Fuck that, he's here to play a concert. And you know what, I wouldn't want to be backed into making any political statement out of the blue, while on stage.

What?! Are you serious?

Pretty much everything I said was wrong? How do you figure that?

Here's my primary claim: "This article is debunking the idea that there are probiotic benefits to eating dirt, which isn't what we're talking about at all"

My claim was that the page you linked is clearly talking about digestive health, not the immune system.

Let's look at the first sentence in the header

Will eating dirt improve gut health?

I'd say that's pretty clear. But wait, that's not the whole header, what does the rest of it say?

According to the Hygiene Hypothesis, ingesting dirt will strengthen our immune system right?

So it's worse than I thought, immediately, right off the bat, this page is already jumbling the concepts of digestive health and immune system. Just odd.

Look, I'm perfectly willing to concede that there are no real digestive benefits to eating dirt. But then I never made that claim. I have no idea what your motivation is, but you should stop spreading misinformation.

Don't infections lead to producing antibodies?

This article is debunking the idea that there are probiotic benefits to eating dirt, which isn't what we're talking about at all. We don't care about the beneficial bacteria, they don't build your immune system, they're irrelevant. It states right at the beginning that there are harmful pathogens in dirt, which is exactly the point. Those harmful pathogens are literally the only thing that can build the immune system.

Oh good, that's better.

That is hilarious.

I spent a while trying to figure out how a cat could possibly long press a power button, even pressing it at all should be a challenge...

Then I remembered that most people use laptops.

I would be impressed if a cat could hold the power button in for several seconds on my tower, you have to depress the button about a 1/4 inch.

Lol, Tim Apple. Who was it that said that? Was it Biden?