And nothing of value was lost
this post was submitted on 08 Oct 2024
141 points (94.3% liked)
Movies and TV Shows
2062 readers
298 users here now
A community for entertainment industry news and general discussion about movies and TV shows.
Rules:
- Be civil.
- Please do not link to pirated content.
- No spoilers in the title of submissions. And please use spoiler MarkDown in the body of discussions. This is a courtesy to other users.
- Comments solely criticizing headlines and/or journalism will be removed for being off-topic.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
This makes sense. With all the great tv shows getting canceled before they even have a chance to develop, I think it is only fair that something this lackluster suffer the same fate.
Ah, so there's at least one good thing that came from Max removing a bunch of cartoons from the platform. Not exactly equivalent exchange, but I'll take the dubs where I can.
It wasn’t great but it also wasn’t half as bad as the internet said.
I only have one criteria. Either I enjoy watching a show, or I don't enjoy it. This thing caused me psychological pain in just the first 10 minutes. I think it was at least half as bad as the worst reviews called it.
Bad media happens all the damn time. The degree to which this got singled out was always just weird.
The true measure of progress is when media featuring minorities can flop and not be a bigger deal than all the other flops starring white men.
Personally I thought it was the sexualization of these teenagers that was the problem.
A rare take on Lemmy lol. I agree, it was a completely odd tone compared to the original.
Yeah that's kinda how I feel about The Acolyte. Liked parts of it, but most was just kinda lame but not really a big deal as everyone else making it out to be. Things just suck sometimes.
The main problem is just that a lot of this stuff is being tied to huge, (generally) well-remembered franchises so there is more eyes on it, and its directly comparing itself to better works. For example, The Acolyte might be okay by the standards of being just another sci-fi show, or as a fanfiction where the expectations are lower, but not when it puts itself alongside other main-line entries like the original trilogy, or even something modern like The Mandalorian.
Yeah I think you're right as a fanfic. Coming of the heels of Andor too.... I mean everything is gonna look shit compared to that series haha. But I think it's also our first look at The High Republic and honestly expectations are rightfully high (no pun intended) because this is effectively our first peek at something that has nothing to do with the Skywalker era. And it just didn't meet that bar, which kinda puts a bad taste in future endeavors.
Honestly it's a systematic failure of Executive leadership at Disney more than anything. At countless points this project should've been axed or halted for rewrites. Giving that much latitude to an inexperienced show runner is very dangerous.
I just recently defected from reddit for the umpteenth time and it is so wild to see how normal these comments are compared to the cesspool I've gotten so used to. I was ready to delve into how abhorrently bad the show was via the comments, only to find normal people!
get used to it.
also, sometimes you have a good response to a thread and it isn't already the top comment with thousands of upvotes and you actually get to post it.
The Way Life's Meant to Be.
I thought the consensus was pretty accurate.
Yeah, that was my take too. Interesting, and decent overall with no real high points, but it wasn't some kind of horrible show at all. Just kinda meh, more of a fanfic idea than a real show.
Didn't know it existed.
Oh no. I'm so sad I'll make sure to never watch it.
Ohh nooooooo.........
I thought Scrappy Doo was a bad idea. I REALLY like projects that stick to the source material.
There's a REASON that this was popular enough you wanted to make it again. Don't change it. That's stupid.
This is only tangentially related to what you just said, but I find adaptations fascinating because of how permeable the concept of "staying true to the source material" is.
One of the best examples I can think of is the animated movie Nimona, based on a graphic novel (that started as a webcomic) by N.D. Stevenson. The movie changes a heckton from the graphic novel, but in a way that arguably leads to a more authentic adaptation of the "soul" of the graphic novel. An example from the inverse is Shyamalan's adaptation of Avatar: The Last Airbender: there were parts that were copied over, shot for shot, from the animated show, and even this segments that closely followed the source material just didn't work — things that worked in animation don't work in live action and vice versa.
I don't think there's any one interpretation of what the "soul" of a piece of media is, but watching Velma was perplexing because I wondered whether Kaling had actually wanted to make an adapted spin-off, or whether this was a completely separate show that later had a Scooby Doo veneer put on top. I wish I could've better understood what her vision was, because I can't see what, if anything, resonated with Kaling from the original media.
I can’t see what, if anything, resonated with Kaling from the original media
Womp womp
Twas ass anyhow