I don't see how "thread" doesn't make sense. That's how it was in forums as well. I also think "article" is way worse than "link", because not every link is an article.
this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2023
11 points (100.0% liked)
/kbin meta
5 readers
2 users here now
Magazine dedicated to discussions about the kbin itself. Provide feedback, ask questions, suggest improvements, and engage in conversations related to the platform organization, policies, features, and community dynamics. ---- * Roadmap 2023 * m/kbinDevlog * m/kbinDesign
founded 1 year ago
Magazine
The dictionary says:
A periodical containing a collection of articles, stories, pictures, or other features.
I think it fits the literal definition of magazine, here on kbin a magazine is a collection of articles, stories, pictures or other features
Link
When you create a link you literally paste a link on the form that redirects to the article in another website
Thread - Post
A thread is a new topic. With your question you opened a new thread.
A post a single entry in a thread. Your question was the first post of your new thread, my comment is the second post in your thread.
Comment: to make a statement of one's opinion
Discuss: to talk about (an issue) usually from various points of view and for the purpose of arriving at a decision or opinion
Most people participate to make a comment and that's all
Badges - Labels
I think badges don't work? So who cares?
They don't sound like broken English at all, they are very literal and self explanatory. Maybe you are bad at English?
Magazine makes sense as a differentiation from lemmy's community. The concept is different so a different word is needed. Thread feels like a throwback to reddit, but it makes sense in the threadverse concept.
I agree on blog though. There post feels cumbersome. Badges could probably use a rewording, but tag makes more sense to me there as an accepted word.
"bin" would make sense and is also a little funny.
I agree that tags makes more sense, but this word is used already
Perhaps it would be a better idea to replace Tags to Hashtags and Badges to Tags ?
What is conceptually different about a kbin magazine to a lemmy community?
As far I know the grouping of the hashtags with the articles and links, in one container is specific to kbin. I like the concept. I may be wrong though. I have not spent much time on Lemmy.
@derin @mack123
here little observation https://kbin.social/m/arknights/p/911556 there is some differences...
Changing magazine to community is fine (though I don't really mind magazine).
I think thread should stay as is. Feels much more distinct than post, which could more easily refer to both threads & microblogs.
Link should stay. Makes it very clear what it does.
Post should definitely be changed, but I don't get why it can't just be microblog instead of blog. Makes it immediately clear what it's for since there's a microblogs tab in the header.
Commented is fine. Again, much more clear about what it means.
Badges don't really do anything yet tmk, so I'd hold off on renaming them.
/kbin plans to eventually support every content type from federated software, and because of this, we cannot actually reserve the name
post to only one type of it. Still, microblog posts/toots/tweets need to be renamed and I prefer to call them Notes. This is already used in ActivityStream dictionary, and in Misskey and ~~Calckey~~ Firefish.
I dislike Notes because it is used in so many other ways also. Notes in other contexts are very often private. Post, Blog, and Microblog are all clearly shared. (I realize some might wonder, "How could anyone think that creating a new item called Note is private?!" I simply offer the feedback that the term Notes is used elsewhere to connote notes to oneself, and would prefer not to add any potential confusion.)
And I have realised right now, than Article has been renamed to Thread here. Somewhat unfortunable, because IMO any Reddit-like posts (Including Link and Photo [unless moved somewhere else]) should be called like that, not only articles.
Some of these things are being discussed at the Codeberg. There's some issues opened like #406 - Rename "Microblog" in header to "Posts" for consistency., or other ones requesting feedback like #680 - Rename 'posts' to 'microposts' everywhere. Truly, the best place to put these ideas or thoughts is on the Codeberg. That's where the action is - but it never hurts to discuss here too, just may not be passed along.
I agree with changing magazine to community, but mostly for the sake of consistency across the fediverse. Changing posts to microposts or something similar will add some clarity, so it might be a good idea as well.
But the rest seems fine to me as is tbh.
Magazine ->Community
Strong agreement.
Link -> Article
Maybe Link -> Website even, 'cause it's not always an actual news article.
Thread -> Post
Agree, mainly because I think most of us would say "I'm going to post this on kbin" but I haven't found a verb I like for ...starting? a new 'thread' lol. "I'm going to thread this on kbin"??
And also for branding issues lol, vs that big company.
Post (In microblog) -> Blog
Room for improvement here, but good start I think.
Commented -> Discussed
I think Comments is fine. Discussion is fine. I actually think this is where "threads" could have been used lol, but let's not.
Badges -> Labels
Labels is good. Badges isn't quite right. Stamp? Banner? Flag?
Okay, yeah. I do slightly prefer 'website' but I'm having trouble disagreeing with you here lmao. I'm willing to leave 'link' alone, if we make the other ones less ambiguous!
Actually it's a very good idea about the article/website I'll edit the post
And my commented I mean a button on hot/newest/active/commented where it shows threads (posts) with most comments(I think)
I think what's meant by a website is actually a webpage.
i understand why people wanna go from magazine to community or maybe even subbin? but thats gonna suuuuck for mags with mag in their name like @MagHub D:
view more: next ›