My favorite part is how the devil is judging the contest himself, and even with that huge advantage he's still like "nah he's just better rip"
this post was submitted on 11 Aug 2024
747 points (100.0% liked)
196
16573 readers
2287 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
There's a subtext that you guys are missing. The devil wins whether he says Johnny won or lost.
- If the devil wins, he gets Johnny's soul per the terms of the bet.
- If Johnny wins, the devil gets Johnny's soul because he's committing multiple deadly sins purely by boasting and challenging the devil for a golden fiddle: pride, greed, vanity.
If he deems Johnny the winner, Johnny is less likely to challenge the decision, and he's also more likely to continue committing the sins of pride and vanity (by boasting of his victory over the Devil Himself).
Johnny's only chance to avoid his fate (per most strains of the Christian faith) is to acknowledge and repent/confess/absolve his sins by seeking divine mercy. The devil knows this is unlikely.
Johnny lost as soon as he uttered his first line.
It's okay Johnny's Protestant he just has to repent
even if he wasn't, that golden fiddle would have bought him many indulgences
The boy said "My name's Johnny,"
"And it might be a sin"
"So I'd uh... I'd better not"
"I'm actually gonna go."
Except everyone is a sinner by default, so what's the downside? That's the problem with these "temptation" parables. Nothing Johnny could do himself would ever avoid that fate, so why act like it?
I'm just pointing out that within the constructs of the predominant Christian mythologies... Johnny's fucked himself over unless he recognizes he's being a shit and atones for it.
Whether you assign any validity to the underlying dogma is an individual choice. People have a tendency to overlook logical inconsistencies in their faith frameworks, in any case.
A solid gold fiddle would weigh hundreds of pounds and sound awful. Maybe he just wanted to get rid of it.
johnny has toes of adamantium and leg muscles like steel cable
Like Johnny wouldn't immediately melt it down or sell it.
and he even cheated by having a band.
It is a cautious tale, it warns you that if you dont make deals with the devil you won't live up to your full potential, and fuck consequences.
🔫 I lied, I don't have Netflix, put your shoes back on. We're going to the crossroads
I didn't do it for my family. I did it... for line go up.
I liked to see the line go up.
🫡🇺🇸🏈💵🇺🇸🙏⛪️🇺🇸☕️🛢️🇺🇸🫡
Greed is good
So there's three schools of thought about the Devil v. Johnny match:
The First: America wins, as is also informed by The Devil and Daniel Webster (1936)
The Second: Rock and Roll wins, as is informed by The Devil and Daniel Mouse (1978) also Rock & Rule (1983) also Crossroads (1986)^†^
The Third: Johnny's victory against the devil may be the start of Johnny's story, in which he gets noted by the labels, performs for three albums, makes it to the top of the radio charts and goes on tour during which he has sex with an uncountable number of groupies, tries out all the drugs, does a Tonight Show interview on Heroin, and dies before thirty, either to an overdose, an assassination by a crazed fan, suicide without any clear cause or an equally mysterious mob hit. (Id est, is a 20th century music GOAT)
† The devil's been tightly involved in music since time immemorial, not only being credited (blamed) for Rock & Roll but also its predecessor, blues. Also ragtime and romanticism. And then there's Niccolò Paganini, who, according to the Church, sold his soul to the devil to gain his violin superpowers, and denied him a proper burial for fifty years after his death (and a lot of pressure from his family estate). Paganini developed modern violin techniques and his Caprices 1-24 are used in violin bravura competitions. (Yes, I digress. I know. I like to talk about it.)
All that said, the Devil in stories seems to be a sucker for musician virtuosos who perform their best for him, and he may secretly just love a good jam.
I thought it was: 1. The devil defeats Johnny, 2. Johnny defeats the devil but disappears after, and 3. Johnny defeats the devil and returns as a child to warn the Pope.
Going down to Georgia implies that Georgia is under hell.
I have lived in Georgia, and I can confirm that this is true...
well it's technically lower than Hell, Michigan on the map
It's under Russia, so yeah.
Not to be that guy, but there's at least one Grimm's fairy tale where a peasant tricks the devil.
To be fair, the song isnt about tricking the devil and using one's wits to overcome terrible odds or such like that, this random guy is just that good that he can just enter into a contest with a supernatural power and win it honestly. Id bet stories like that exist in other cultures, surely, but still probably arent as common as ones where the human must resort to tricks or suffers for hubris. Then again, the song also suggests the devil hasnt been too successful lately, so maybe this version of the character just isnt terribly powerful in the first place.
There's a Buddhist story, about an old monk teaching a young one.
The young one, goes outside and the old one is chopping wood. The old monk tells how amazing he is at it The young one immediately asks why are you bragging? It's against the teachings.
The old monk replied, I'm not and proceeds to perfectly split five pieces. Describing your skill actually is not bragging is the moral. Or something like that
Probably every single European bridge called "Devil's Bridge" has a story about how he was tricked into making it in one single night and then denied his prize because
- they made a rooster sing before dawn because the contract specified that as the deadline
- they made an animal cross the bridge first because the first soul was to be taken per contract
- they bully him into giving it up with some divine intercession.
Sometimes with really lame tricks - "fill my boot with gold in exchange for my soul" (cuts sole out of boot)
I don't want no stupid stories about hubris I just want the bard version of doom
I prefer the Tribute version of this story.
It's pretty good. But it isn't the greatest song in the world.
It's just a tribute.
Isn't there a second song where Johnny loses his soul because of the arrogance?
Mark O'Conner did a sequel with Johnny Cash as the narrator, Travis Tritt as the devil, and Marty Stuart as Johnny. It's called "The Devil Comes Back to Georgia" and Johnny wins the that one again, this time with even more hubris than before. Good song though, if you like the fiddle Mark O'Conner is incredibly talented.