this post was submitted on 29 Jun 2024
8 points (100.0% liked)

Cosmere

550 readers
1 users here now

This community is a place to discuss books in Brandon Sanderson's Cosmere--the shared universe where most of his novels take place. Please take a moment to review our rules!

1. Show respect to others

Every interaction in the community must be kind, respectful, and welcoming. No person should ever feel threatened, harassed, or unwelcome. Do not engage in hate speech, harassment, insults, personal attacks, trolling, or arguing in bad faith. Interpretation of this rule is subject to the moderators' discretion. Please remember the human.

2. Spoilers not permitted in post titles

Post titles must never reveal spoilers. This includes no direct quotes from the books. Title wording should be vague if necessary. Grey areas are up to the moderators' discretion.

3. Use spoiler markup for all spoiler posts

Please cover all posts in a spoiler tag. Spoilers outside the scope of a post must be hidden with spoiler markup and the scope indicated. The scope is determined by the post tag flair along with any additional restrictions placed by the OP.

You spoiler tag like this:

::: Spoiler Spoiler Tag

message here

:::

in order to get:

Book Name HereStuff about the book in here

4. Post must be tagged for spoilers

All posts must be tagged to indicate the level of expected spoilers in the link/post and comments. The spoiler scope should include the name of the book or books, such as [Book Name] or [Book Series]. You may also say [No Spoilers] if you don't want any spoilers at all. Be as specific as possible. You can even say [Book Name Ch 34], for example.

5. No excessive reposting

Identical content may not be reposted within, by default, a two week period. This period may be adjusted at the moderators' discretion.

6. Posts must be on topic

Posts must be related to the Cosmere. Posts relating to sensitive topics (such as politics, religions, etc.) will be subject to greater scrutiny.. Meta discussions related to the community are generally permitted. Self promotion for money is disallowed. Art, podcasts, videos and other such actual content is allowed.

7. Respect intellectual property

Piracy and copyright infringement are strictly forbidden. With some exceptions, all content must comply with Dragonsteel's licensing and fanart policies. Artwork must be attributed and may not be posted against the artist's wishes. Fan art should be marked as [OC] or credited to the original artist. If AI was used as a tool, please also mark the post [AI: Tool Used], for example [AI: Midjourney].

8. Leaked content is not permitted

Content which is released outside of Brandon Sanderson's wishes is not allowed under any circumstances. Pre-release content publicly released by Brandon, Dragonsteel Entertainment, or a publisher is okay if marked appropriately for spoilers.

9. Posts must be thoughtful and unique (Except Fri-Sun, PST)

Posts must provide original thoughts, questions, ideas, news, or interpretations of the books that can be discussed by the community.

Restricted content often includes: memes; images reminiscent of something in the books; AI-generated artwork; photos of books, bookshelves, merchandise; casting posts; photos of pets; etc. This content is not restricted in /c/brandonsanderson if you’d like to post there.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

So, finished RoW, I did not read the halfs (yet?) Edgedencer & Dawnshard - instead I cheated a bit and looked up the summary for these (Dawnshard mainly) as I was too hungry for more "spice" of the SA story so I wanted to continue with next SA book straight away. I did read all of the current Mistborn series we have before SA though about a year or something ago

So I do have some notion about the...shards, investiture and stuff but... I am still confused how the Cosmere magic works in general - I know that magic (Investiture) is different for each planet/system of the Cosmere and guessing it has something to do with the specific shards of that system... ?
⠀⠀

Well, if anyone wants to chime in with pointers I would be very thankful!
Meanwhile I will be scouring the wiki and WoBs to get a better picture.

top 5 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 4 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

I do recommend the stormlight short stories, they are both quite good.

What info are you specifically looking for?

Mistborn and Stormlight all

There are shards that represent certain concepts, ruin, preservation, honour, cultivation etc. people hold these shards, but are, influenced by it's intent the longer they hold it.

Generally, each shard has picked a planet/solar system to settle and create/enhance their population.

Each systems magic tends to end up mirroring in some way the intent of the shard that created it. Honours require oaths, Ruin's requires stealing power off others etc.

Some magic systems work for their users off planet (you have seen this!), others are more difficult.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

*grunts* I should not have read SA so fast (according to the receipt, it's exactly month and two days).

Thank you both @[email protected] and @[email protected] for the explanations.
I feel like one of the ten fools!

I will have to read it all again. Seems I've missed some key details in both MB and SA as I have hard times connecting some of the stuff you have mentioned to what I am pretty sure I should already know.
Also should have read SA in my native language.
And and should have read Mistborn: Secret History ...

On the bright side, now I don't have to worry what to read (the whole) next year, will probably wait for WaT to release in December and start with everything again. Thanks again though!

[–] [email protected] 3 points 5 months ago

The more of the Cosmere you read, the more things will connect and the clearer the picture will be. Every time I re-read SA, I see new connections I'd missed before. Some of that is familiarity with the magics of other planets, because that changes your read from "character did a weird thing" to "hey! that's magic from this other planet; why/how has it turned up here?"

In the earlier books, the crossovers between worlds/magics and the underlying "how things work" are more subtle and you'll miss things on first read. In more recent books, it's more overt.

Some of that is because of how much the protagonists themselves understand. For example, in the first Mistborn trilogy the characters really don't understand what's going on on their own planet, so of course you don't get a good explanation. In Secret History, the POV character does run into people who know quite a lot about what is going on, so when Secret History revisits the events of the main trilogy you're able to understand the forces driving those catastrophic events.

The characters in SA started off thinking magic wasn't real and knowing nothing about realms and worlds beyond their own. They are learning a lot through their spren and Hoid, but there is still a lot that they don't know. And you as the reader are learning along with them.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 5 months ago

There are some fundamental concepts that span all of the systems. Investiture is the "mana" here but can show up as matter too, like the mists or shardblades. Investiture always wants to be used, and in a way that rewards people for satisfying the Intent of the shard it came from, like how radiants progress by personal growth and deepening the bond. When it's being used, it makes vibrations that can be picked up by Seekers and the like.
Magic systems in a particular area are affected by what's going on (or happened in the past) with the shards there. Like how the Dor works because 2 dead shards are corked up and trying to get out. The shards can also consciously affect the rules to an extent, like putting limiters on how much power the radiants get. There are a bunch of side stories set on worlds with no shards, there's still magic but it gets wacky because shards fought there once or something. There's also magic that Ado himself set up, that tends to be either subtle like Hoid's stories or stone singing, or bonkers megastructures, with no in between.
Most magic has a Connection to the world it came from, but people figure out how to bypass that and you get the Cosmere Space Age.
Connection is something you have already seen a lot of, in the form of Bondsmith shenanigans and to a lesser extent the wind runner lashings.
The Intent of the user also affects how the magic works, it's why you can use magic without realizing, or do really complex stuff without doing all the math yourself. It's usually bundled up with a Command, where you give a verbal order and your Intent kind of gives it flavor.
The fact that different metals do different things shows up a lot, but it's not 100% consistent what each metal does.
And then there's the 3 realms. You've seen how the first 2 work, and that whole scene at the end of RoW is them looking into the third. The third is also where souls are (including the bits that govern memories and what magic you can use), Investiture returns there after it's been used, and all of time and space are one there. There's no alternate timeliness or time travel, but you can see the branching possibilities for the future, or play "what if" games like burning electrum. When something is looking at all of that for you and handing you the TLDR, it's called Fortune.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago)

This is my very rough back of the napkin explanation but I’ll give it a try.

There are 3 aspects of the world. The physical, the spiritual and the cognitive.

The one thing all of the magic systems have in common is that the different shards affect how these different realms are used to affect others. Mainly through investiture (the spiritual potential energy if you will) to affect the physical, cognitive and spiritual realms.

In Roshar, for example. Investiture allows some to specify intent into the cognitive realm. Where the mental perceptions of things exist and have a kind of will over time. And when those are convinced to change it impacts the physical realm. The energy source allowing that intent to be work is Stormlight.

While in Scadrial (from Mistborn) there are actually multiple magic systems. One of which allows consumption of some aspect of the physical realm to gain enough investiture to affect the cognitive realm/spiritual realm to affect the physical (by changing various forces of attraction, repulsion, etc). That’s not even including Metallurgy which is its own thing.

I definitely recommend reading the Mistborn series where you’ll see his magic system from a different perspective and start to see parallels.

But at the end of the day there’s

  • Mental will or intent by somebody with a link or “investiture” to a worlds magic system.

  • The things to be changed/affected in one or more of the planes of existence by using the spiritual investiture

  • The investiture source usually from consuming something from one of those planes such as metals, life force, cognitive.

For example I think the Nightwatcher tends to impose some kind of cognitive cost for her boon which affects spiritual bonds. So even in Roshar you have the impact of multiple shards and can see how they tend to warp how the magic works.