A community for those that would like to get away from Google.
Here you may post anything related to DeGoogling, why we should do it or good software alternatives!
Be respectful even in disagreement
No advertising unless it is very relevent and justified. Do not do this excessively.
No low value posts / memes. We or you need to learn, or discuss something.
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Basically an advertisement for their services, but since they're shitting on Google's ad revenue model I'm all for it.
I will not shit on Google completely myself though, because I do appreciate (other than a few naughty shenanigans they've pulled recently) their work on the Android kernel.
Completely self serving though. Mobile is a personal data goldmine and Google gotta dig into that one way or another and if folks can contribute to that side with bug fixes, great.
And Facebook has some of the best open source work of all time, from the react ecosystem to making php feasible, to LLMs. There's certainly a ton missing and a lot of it is for their own products, but some of it goes far beyond their own needs
Facebook also did unethical human testing and debatably broke democracy and the social fabric
Just be even handed. Praise the good, denounce the bad, and keep in mind these are monstrously large companies and the people that did the good probably have little to do with the ones that did the bad
Google shouldn't get a pass because they bought Android and only partially used that ownership to control the ecosystem and push their own products
This is honestly what puts me off using Proton. They advertise way too much and way too aggressively. It's just a bad vibe for a company that's trying to set itself up as an alternative to Google.
I use Tutanota but I'm looking to find something else because I'm sick of platforms that lock you into their ecosystem, and the fact they don't provide any means of using other mail clients like Thunderbird has become a deal breaker.
Problem is there doesn't seem to be consensus on third place.
They advertise way too much and way too aggressively.
I understand your feeling, but I think massive advertising is needed. This is high level marketing, basically telling the general public there is another way other than big tech. Most people don't know this to know there are options to choose...so they don't.
I understand your feeling, but I think massive advertising is needed.
Why is it "needed"?
This is high level marketing, basically telling the general public there is another way other than big tech
Why do they care about attracting all these people?
Every one of them increases their operating costs, and doesn't provide revenue if they stay in the free tier. Why do they want to increase their numbers so badly?
Why isn't it enough to just make a good product and let that be what brings people in?
The only reason for this kind of aggressive advertising is because they're making a push for growth. They want to become one of those "big tech" companies.
Let me be clear, I'm not shaming them for advertising their services. But I'm uncomfortable with the scale and aggression with which they do it. They are putting money into this, and a lot of it. It's not like they're a non-profit, the end goal is pretty obvious here.
We've been through this before with so many other tech companies, Proton will be no different. It's just entering the honeymoon phase, is all.
This is just a long advertisement
It’s their company blog.
Oh absolutely, it's just an ad for Proton products. That doesn't make the point about degoogling any less relevant.
What are the alternatives though? Self-hosting an email server is practically impossible because spam detection will block you on every turn.
any service that grows enough will become a google there is no way around it. I cant imagine a situation where half the world uses an email server and governments dont fall on it
There is no reason other than greed that tech companies have to have their fingers in so many pies. Regulators could split Google up - search separated from ads and separated from other services.
It's not the size so much as the breadth of it's influence. We've gotten used to the idea that tech companies like Google and Microsoft do everything. But they're only doing everything so they can get at every bite of our data. An email service doesn't need to be run alongside a search engine or a news aggregator or an ad company. And certainly doesn't need integration between all those things.
Doesn't need to be as wide coverage as Google. If you only provide email service and half the population of US population is using your service, the government will come after you and ask for unlimited access to people's emails. That is already quite a lot of data. But agreed when you are like google, you basically have every piece of knowledge required to completely map someone's life. Fucked up shit.
This is a good thing, but it is too much advertising proton's services
I'm all for anything that can replace Google
it's not technically self hosting (and i don't really want to do that) but i've had my own domains since the last 90s and dreamhost since 2007 and i don't even need gmail or another email service. it's nice.
You can use the Google Play store anonymously with the Aurora Store.
Other than that, you can probably find free and open sources alternatives instead of using Proton.
I've been trying to, and it would be easy enough with individual users having an @gmail account. My situation is ten people on a custom domain (anyone remember "Google apps for your domain"?) and that is particularly difficult to extricate from!
You can easily migrate custom domain that to proton for email, calendar, and drive. What you'll struggle with is docs and sheets.
I'd like to drop this amazing blog here: https://digdeeper.club/articles/email.xhtml#protonmail
Thanks for the info
You can also buy a domain name and get cheap email hosting. Less annoying than what I hear proton is. My hosting uses Titan Mail, they'll occasionally pop up about a new thing they're working on but I can just be like "no thanks" and they go "cool."
I've been using proton for several years and have not found it annoying.
Not sure what you've heard is annoying.
10 years later: De-Proton your life.
100%. They'll eventually turn evil. I self-host as much as I can.