- Show that the infinite multiplication
(1+1/1)(1+1/2)(1+1/3)...does not converge.
this post was submitted on 16 May 2024
10 points (100.0% liked)
Daily Maths Challenges
189 readers
1 users here now
Share your cool maths problems.
Complete a challenge:
- Post your solution in comments, if it is exactly the same as OP's solution, let us know.
- Have fun.
Post a challenge:
- Doesn't have to be original, as long as it is not a duplicate.
- Challenges not riddles, if the post is longer than 3 paragraphs, reconsider yourself.
- Optionally include solution in comments, let it be clear this is not a homework help forums.
- Tag [unsolved] if you don't have a solution yet.
- Please include images, if your question includes complex symbols, attach a render of the maths.
Feel free to contribute to a series by DMing the OP, or start your own challenge series.
founded 6 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
solution
The terms can be rewritten as:(2/1) * (3/2) * (4/3) * ... * ((n+1)/n) * ...
Each numerator will cancel with the next denominator. In total everything cancels, so the answer is the empty product, 1.
...Wait...
Uhm, ignore that. Rather, consider the products we get when multiplying. We get: 2/1. 6/2. 24/6. Etc. That is, we have:
Π (n = 1 to k) (n+1)/n = (k+1)! / k! = (k+1)k!/k! = k+1
k+1 clearly goes to infinity as k → ∞, so our product diverges to infinity.
::: spoiler solution Isn't this already the result of your 1st formula? As the denominator of the last fraction you wrote down,
(n+1)/n, cancels out with the counter of the one right before,n/(n-1), which you didn't write down. Thus the whole product up to the nth term reads after cancellation of neighbouring counters and denominator pairs(n+1)/1 →∞ when n→∞.reply
Yes - I mostly left the first part in for the humor (it was legitimately my first stab at the problem), but it gives the same result, just in a way that's a little harder (to me, at least) to see. The cancellation is unbalanced: Each numerator cancels with the next denominator, which necessarily brings with it the next numerator - you've always got the next numerator in line, as-is, after any number of canceled pairs. So while everything cancels out in the limit, the product up to n equals n+1, and so the limit of the product is ∞.