this post was submitted on 12 Oct 2023
1076 points (91.3% liked)

Crappy Design

3004 readers
72 users here now

Noticed that theres no equivalent to r/crappydesign here yet so i made one

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
[email protected]
1076
Hey Google, go fuck yourself entirely (sh.itjust.works)
submitted 1 year ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
270 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 19 points 1 year ago

I'm not the one you responded to, but I'll say why I think it's an asshole design:

  1. They have a dominant market position
  2. They have encouraged people to not just put fun videos on the platform, but to put critical life-saving videos there.
  1. At first, they had few ads, or ads that were always skippable
  2. Now that they have a near monopoly, they're adding more ads, and making more of them unskippable.
  3. To watch a lifesaving video, that was posted at a time when there were no real ads or all ads were skippable, you may have to watch a series of 30 second ads.

Then there's the fact that virtually every video requires ads before you view it, when you might only need to see 10s of the video to know that it's not relevant. Putting multiple ads before you're allowed to see those 10 seconds is an asshole move. Then there's the sheer quantity of ads. The last time I tried to watch a few music videos without an ad blocker I think it was at least 25% ad time.

Removing the ability to skip is also a major asshole move. The whole justification for skippable ads was that consumers wouldn't skip ads that were good and relevant. If the advertiser was doing their job and making good ads, and YouTube was doing a good job and finding the right audience for those ads, then in theory the ads wouldn't be skipped. If an advertiser was upset that users were skipping ads, YouTube could push back and say that either their ad sucked, or that they had mistargeted the ad. Now they seem to be admitting that their ad targeting is bullshit, or that they don't care if the ad isn't relevant to the user, the user has to watch it regardless.

But, most of this hinges on the enshittification happening once the platform has become a monopoly. If YouTube only had a 20% market share, asshole moves would push people to competitors. But, the key thing is that they lost money or barely broke even until all their competitors had folded, and then they started making things worse.