this post was submitted on 15 Aug 2023
13 points (93.3% liked)

No Stupid Questions (Developer Edition)

921 readers
1 users here now

This is a place where you can ask any programming / topic related to the instance questions you want!

For a more general version of this concept check out [email protected]

Icon base by Lorc under CC BY 3.0 with modifications to add a gradient

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Do I master Typescript if I master Javascript ? Is Typescript syntax different ? Answers appreciated, thank you !

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] bignavy 1 points 1 year ago

I think sometimes the difference between strongly typed and loosely typed is easier to explain in terms of workflow. It's possible (note: not necessarily a good idea, but possible) to start writing a function in vanilla JavaScript without any real idea of what it's going to output. Is it going to return a string? Is it going to return null, because it's performing some action to a variable? Or is it going to return that variable? And vanilla JS is good with that.

But that same looseness that can be kind of useful when you're brainstorming or problem solving can result in unexpected behavior. For instance, I write a function that prepares a string for additional processing. For the purposes of this conversation, let's say that it removes white spaces and any non-letter or number characters, and then returns the transformed string.

What happens if I feed a number (integer) to this function instead of a string? What about a number with a decimal (float)? Does my function (and/or JavaScript) treat them as literal strings? Does it remove the decimal from the float, since it's a non-letter, non-number value?

Without Typescript, you have to either a) write your code in such a way that you ensure that the situation never comes up (i.e. by validating inputs, or by being very careful about when and how this function is used), or b) you have to handle those weird cases, which turns a cute little three line function into a 30 line monster with a switch case and typecasting. And truthfully, on any project 'at scale' you're going to have to do both.

With Typescript, you specify that this function takes in a string, and returns a string, and that's it. Then, when another dev (or you, in six weeks when you've forgotten all about this function that you wrote) tries to send in a boolean, or a float, or an array of strings, Typescript is going to blow up. Nope. Can't do that. And they (it's more fun to think of it as future you) will have to follow the rules that you put in place by writing the function the way you did, which just means being careful enough to cast a float or integer into a string before passing it, or concatenating an array, or whatever.

Strongly typed languages expect you to write functions with the end state you're expecting in mind. You've already got the solution in your head before you start typing, at least enough to know what type of data goes in and what type of data goes out.

It also hides (but doesn't totally get rid of!) some of the sillier things that JavaScript does because it's not strongly typed. True + True should probably never equal 2.

As to OP's question, though - if you know how to do things in JavaScript (.trim(), for example), then you know how to do a thing in Typescript. Manipulating data in JavasScript and manipulating data in TypeScript is identical - but TypeScript is also watching what the types of the different data types being used, and throwing up the BS flag when you get too loose with what you're doing (or don't think through the consequences of your design decisions).