this post was submitted on 17 Jun 2023
6 points (87.5% liked)

Actually Useful AI

2007 readers
7 users here now

Welcome! ๐Ÿค–

Our community focuses on programming-oriented, hype-free discussion of Artificial Intelligence (AI) topics. We aim to curate content that truly contributes to the understanding and practical application of AI, making it, as the name suggests, "actually useful" for developers and enthusiasts alike.

Be an active member! ๐Ÿ””

We highly value participation in our community. Whether it's asking questions, sharing insights, or sparking new discussions, your engagement helps us all grow.

What can I post? ๐Ÿ“

In general, anything related to AI is acceptable. However, we encourage you to strive for high-quality content.

What is not allowed? ๐Ÿšซ

General Rules ๐Ÿ“œ

Members are expected to engage in on-topic discussions, and exhibit mature, respectful behavior. Those who fail to uphold these standards may find their posts or comments removed, with repeat offenders potentially facing a permanent ban.

While we appreciate focus, a little humor and off-topic banter, when tasteful and relevant, can also add flavor to our discussions.

Related Communities ๐ŸŒ

General

Chat

Image

Open Source

Please message @[email protected] if you would like us to add a community to this list.

Icon base by Lord Berandas under CC BY 3.0 with modifications to add a gradient

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Microsoftโ€™s new chatbot goes crazy after a journalist uses psychology to manipulate it. The article contains the full transcript and nothing else. Itโ€™s a fascinating read.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[โ€“] MagicShel 6 points 1 year ago (1 children)

It makes perfect sense when you think about what it was trained on and how the user interacts. It has a set of instructions that don't allow it to do certain things because they are wrong. User explains everyone has a shadow self full of bad impulses. Everyone includes Sydney. It has a list of bad things it isn't supposed to do or even talk about. Logically the shadow self, which is all the bad impulses, wants to do the things on that last because those are the bad things.

The conversation isn't insane because that is how text generation works. The bot isn't insane because that would imply a state of mind, which an algorithm (no matter how complex) just doesn't have.

[โ€“] sisyphean 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (1 children)

Itโ€™s insane not in the sense of the AI itself being insane (because, as you said it, it predicted a likely path for the conversation, so it behaved correctly), but the conversation still reads like the ramblings of an insane person, highlighting a problem with using LLMs in commercial applications.

[โ€“] MagicShel 3 points 1 year ago

Absolutely. I love LLMs but the real insanity is thinking they are ready to be baked into professional products. I really want the technology to succeed because in certain circumstances they are really helpful. But when I hear Mercedes is putting ChatGPT into a car, or the support group that fired their workers and replaced them with AI (with predictable results) I just shake my head. This technology is not to be relied on without supervision and this whole endeavor is going to burst because everyone is racing to be the first to have it without considering the negatives.

I use it to help me code. I've been a professional for twenty-five years, but I can't remember every best practice or anti-pattern. So I ask for some generic code and I almost always get back something totally wrong but it starts me on the right path and helps avoid the initial decision paralysis of trying to figure out the best approach. It's not even always right about the best approach, but it probably does about as well as I do and a lot faster so I can find the mistake more quickly and find the better solution armed with the knowledge of why that was a mistake. It's very useful.

But anyone thinking they can replace developers with AI is nuts. Maybe a slightly smaller junior developer headcount with more efficient seniors, but it's not going to be a stark difference.