To discuss how to grow and manage communities / magazines on Lemmy, Mbin, Piefed and Sublinks
Resources:
Megathreads:
Rules:
I actually agree with @[email protected] 's approach
I've actually previously asked users to edit their posts in the communities that I mod and it's working pretty well.
To me, asking people to do something first makes more sense as most users are reasonable considerate people.
Plus it just seems like the more polite method of doing things as an admin
Well for me, its contextual. I mod [email protected] currently. If you read the sidebar, and just observe how I post - that's basically the formatting I'd like. Other people on there aren't always following it. Now, I don't really think its a huge problem currently - I'm glad other people are using it. I'm trying to grow it - but some of the 'errors' are really minor in regards to the post formatting.
In other cases, it's just cleaning things up for aesthetic purposes. Fixing typos etc. Small things like that, you know?
Be aware that the more strict your rules are, the lesser people will want to post.
I understand that.
"Please edit your post title to [whatever it should be edited to to reflect community standards]" in the comments from a mod would also resolve the problems you have. In my opinion looking anal about rule enforcement > potential for abuse.
Although I do think if flairs are implemented, mods changing flair would probably be a good option—far less room to change what the original poster is saying to make them look bad.
I mean, and/or the use of bots to automatically instantly remove posts that don't meet the posting format.
Seems like a lot of potential abuse indeed.
Just for reference, was it possible on Reddit?
Nah, mods could set/change flair, but not contents.
Then again users couldn't change their titles either, which we can do here.
No.
Tildes does this with the rationale being that once a post is submitted to a community it belongs to that community. This solves more things than it breaks since you don’t want to participate in a community where mods would abuse this and modlogs are public anyway.
Yeah, I mean if mod edits are public then I don't know how this could be abused meaningfully without completely discrediting your community.
This is a thing on lobsters
Hahahaha, you're kidding, right?
Should mods be able to alter the body too, "for clarity"?
🤦🏼
But I would quietly edit it
🤦🏼🤦🏼
I think if the edit log showing the moderator that edited it, and timestamped was publicly visible then any attempts at vandalism or trolling would obviously backfire.
And "by quietly" I simple mean adjusting it. I have no issue with that edit going on the public record in those circumstances. Just I would do it without necessarily bothering the OP. Or maybe it could ping them too automatically. I don't mind.