Selfhosted

I've solved this on my side with socket activation, which besides giving out the real IP, also has native network performance since it fully skips slirp4netns. You could even set nginx's network to none, but since I also use named networks for internal container DNS, so I kept network set.

I've built my own Nginx image and I'm using Quadlets instead of Compose, so my config is as easy as it gets, the socket file is something like this:

[Unit]
Description=container-nginx

[Socket]
BindIPv6Only=both
ListenStream=443

[Install]
WantedBy=sockets.target

And the quadlet file for NGINX goes like this for me:

[Unit]
Description=Web serving, reverse proxying, caching, load balancing, media streaming, and more.
Requires=nginx.socket
After=nginx.socket

[Container]
Image=localhost/nginx:latest
AutoUpdate=local
Volume=/data/containers/nginx/conf.d:/etc/nginx/conf.d:Z
Volume=/data/containers/nginx/certs:/certs:Z
Network=services.network
# Socket for systemd
Environment="NGINX=3;"

[Service]
Restart=always

If you check the socket activation link, there are a few other examples, but IMO that's the easiest setup out of the 5 examples. You could move NGINX out of the compose setup for easiness or adapt examples 3 to 6 (which invoke podman manually). That said, I wanted to use Caddy for easier certificate management, but it doesn't support socket activation, so this setup kinda hardlocked me to NGINX.

Ran into the real ip problem too in prod where we needed ip6 too and the podman version is too old to have anything newer. But running the proxy with network=host and anything behind is listening on 127.0.0.1:x is working well so far. It's not so elegant as it could be, but it works smoothly.

I struggled with this same problem for a long time before finding a solution. I really didn't want to give up and run my reverse proxy (Traefik in my case) on the host, because then I'd lose out on all the automatic container discovery and routing. But I really needed true client IPs to get passed through for downstream service consumption.

So what I ended up doing was installing only HAProxy on the host, configuring it to proxy all traffic to my containerized reverse proxy via Proxy Protocol (which includes original client IPs!) instead of HTTPS. Then I configured my reverse proxy to expect (and trust) Proxy Protocol traffic from the host. This allows the reverse proxy to receive original client IPs while still terminating HTTPS. And then it can pass everything to downstream containerized services as needed.

I tried several of the other options mentioned in this thread and never got them working. Proxy Protocol was the only thing that ever did. The main downside is there is another moving part (HAProxy) added to the mix, and it does need to be on the host. But in my case, that's a small price to pay for working client IPs.

More at: https://www.haproxy.com/blog/use-the-proxy-protocol-to-preserve-a-clients-ip-address

Podman + Caddy does it for me.

You need to adjust the "minimum" port a user can bind. Podman tells you how to do it (or a quick google search).

By running NPM in an unprivileged LXC without docker or podman. I'm surprised to hear that's been an issue with podman for so long though.

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

5 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 12 acronyms.

[Thread #700 for this sub, first seen 22nd Apr 2024, 04:25] [FAQ] [Full list] [Contact] [Source code]

The issue you linked mentions using pasta where it does work. Have you tried that or is it not a solution at all?